Citoyen
  • Home
  • Feed

Explore

  • Countries
  • Categories
  • Compare
  • My follows

Understand

  • BriefingsBy country and category
  • Deep divesIn-depth analyses
  • Track recordsEach leader's record
  • ReformsTracker and simulators

Data

  • Sources
  • Calendar
  • Method

Citoyen

  • About
  1. World
  2. ›
  3. Environment, energy & climate

Ecological transition: what do the most advanced countries do?

Sweden and France produce almost carbon-free electricity, Denmark most of its own with wind and sun, Norway now sells almost only electric cars, the United Kingdom has closed its coal plants. What these countries did, in electricity, heating and transport, and what research has really evaluated.

Citoyen·Data as of Nov 15, 2026
Scope: OECD countries and large economies: electricity generation by source (Ember), new car sales (IEA), renewable heat in European Union countries (Eurostat), greenhouse-gas emissions on the territory, excluding forests and land (official inventories compiled by the OECD), latest year published.▾

This deep dive is updated at least once a quarter with the new figures. Follow it to get a notification at each update.

Key points

Share of Swedish electricity generated without fossil fuels99%renewables and nuclear in 2025, against 95% in France and 58% in Germany
Share of coal in British electricity0.1%in 2025, against 39% in 2012
Electric cars among new cars sold in Norway97%in 2025, against 25% worldwide and 26% in France
Fall in UK emissions since 199052%greenhouse gases on the territory (1990 – 2024); 32% in France
  • The first lever is electricity. Sweden (99%) and France (95%) generate almost all their electricity without coal, gas or oil, thanks to nuclear and hydro power chosen in the 1970s and 1980s. Denmark gets 70% of its own from wind and sun, against 12% in 2000. Clean electricity then makes clean the heating and cars plugged into it.
  • Putting a price on carbon brings emissions down (evidence level B). Sweden’s 1991 tax, the EU carbon market and the UK’s 2013 price floor have been evaluated with quasi-experimental methods: emissions fall, with no collapse in output. In the United Kingdom, coal’s share of electricity went from 39% in 2012 to 0.1% in 2025.
  • In homes and cars, what works is a set of measures. Norway combined tax exemptions, user advantages and charging points: 97% of new cars there are electric. Sweden and Finland produce more than half of their heat from renewable energy, through district heating and heat pumps, against 31% in France. Renovations often save less than expected (level A).
  • Growth and falling emissions go together in most rich countries. Since 2005, 29 of the 36 countries observed have seen output rise and emissions fall: in France, GDP grew by 23% and emissions fell by 34%. Part of the fall comes from deindustrialisation, and these figures do not count the emissions of imported goods.
How to read these figures

Electricity shares are shares of the country’s generation (Ember), imports excluded. “Low-carbon” groups renewables (hydro, wind, solar, biomass) and nuclear. Renewable heat (Eurostat) counts wood, district heating fed by renewables and the energy captured by heat pumps, in the heating and cooling of buildings and industry. Emissions are those produced on the territory, excluding forests and land, as each country reports them to the United Nations: the emissions of imported goods are not included.

Each measure comes with a level of evidence: A for controlled experiments (random assignment), B for quasi-experimental studies (a policy compared with a control group), C for comparisons of data, D for a plausible, untested hypothesis. Gaps between countries also reflect geography (rivers, wind, sun) and old choices: Norway and Sweden have large dams, France built its nuclear fleet forty years ago. Charts across countries are correlations; they do not point to a model to copy.

1. Who has cut emissions most

Since 1990, the United Kingdom has cut its greenhouse-gas emissions by 52%, Germany by 48%, Denmark by 47%, Sweden by 33% and France by 32%, according to the official inventories. US emissions have stayed close to their 1990 level (3% lower, 1990 – 2022).

These falls have different origins: the end of coal power in the United Kingdom and Denmark, the closure of the oldest plants of former East Germany after 1990, electricity already decarbonised in Sweden and France, where recent progress comes mostly from heating and industry.

Greenhouse-gas emissions on the territory, 1990 = 100

Total excluding land use and forestry, in CO2 equivalent, as reported by each country (inventories compiled by the OECD). 100 = 1990 level.

  • Japan
  • United States
  • Germany
  • France
  • Denmark
  • Sweden
  • United Kingdom

Source:OECD

Show the chart data
PeriodUnited KingdomSwedenDenmarkFranceGermanyUnited StatesJapan
1990100100100100100100100
19911011001151059699101
19929910010610392101102
1993961001109992102102
1994951041159790104106
1995941031119990105108
19969710812910291108109
19979410111610088109108
19989410211110386110104
1999909710710283110106
2000919610110183114108
2001919710410284111106
2002899810310183112108
2003909811010282113108
2004899710210281115108
200588939610279115108
2006889210610080114107
200786911009877115109
20088488959777112103
2009768291947210598
20107890929474108102
20117384849072106106
20127580789073102109
20137377819075105110
20146875758571106106
20156675718572103103
20166275748672101101
20176173718671100100
2018597271836810396
2019577066816410193
202052656274589288
202154676378619790
202252636175609788
20234962567053–84
20244867536852–82

2. Electricity without coal or gas

Sweden generates 99% of its electricity without fossil fuels and France 95%, with nuclear and hydro. The United Kingdom is at 64%, Germany at 58%, the United States at 43% and China at 41%.

The British case is the fastest. In 2013 the country added a floor to the European carbon price: coal power became more expensive than gas, then than offshore wind. Coal’s share fell from 39% in 2012 to 0.1% in 2025; the last plant closed in 2024. Germany, which shut its last nuclear reactors in 2023, still generates 21% of its electricity from coal, China 55%.

Share of electricity generated without fossil fuels (renewables and nuclear)

Share of the country’s electricity generation, imports excluded (Ember).

  • China
  • United States
  • Germany
  • Spain
  • United Kingdom
  • France
  • Sweden

Source:EmberType of source : Research

Show the chart data
PeriodSwedenFranceUnited KingdomSpainGermanyUnited StatesChina
200097%91%25%44%36%29%18%
200196%92%26%48%36%28%20%
200295%91%26%40%36%29%19%
200393%90%25%46%35%29%17%
200496%90%24%41%37%29%19%
200597%89%25%34%37%28%18%
200696%90%24%38%38%29%18%
200797%90%21%38%36%28%17%
200897%90%19%39%38%29%21%
200997%90%25%44%39%31%20%
201094%90%23%54%39%30%20%
201196%90%28%50%38%32%19%
201298%90%31%50%39%31%22%
201397%91%35%60%40%32%22%
201498%94%38%61%42%33%24%
201598%92%45%56%44%33%27%
201698%90%46%60%43%35%28%
201798%88%50%54%45%37%29%
201898%91%52%59%47%37%29%
201998%91%54%59%53%38%31%
202099%91%59%66%56%40%32%
202198%91%55%67%52%40%33%
202298%87%56%63%50%40%34%
202399%92%60%72%56%41%35%
202499%95%65%77%58%42%38%
202599%95%64%75%58%43%41%

Share of coal in electricity generation

The United Kingdom is shown from 1990; the carbon price floor dates from 2013 (Ember).

  • China
  • United States
  • Germany
  • Spain
  • United Kingdom

Source:EmberType of source : Research

Show the chart data
PeriodUnited KingdomSpainGermanyUnited StatesChina
199065%––––
199165%––––
199260%––––
199353%––––
199449%––––
199546%––––
199642%––––
199735%––––
199834%––––
199929%––––
200032%36%52%52%78%
200134%30%51%51%76%
200232%34%51%50%78%
200335%29%51%51%80%
200433%29%49%50%78%
200534%27%47%50%79%
200637%23%46%49%80%
200734%24%47%49%81%
200832%16%44%48%77%
200927%12%43%45%78%
201028%9%42%45%77%
201129%15%43%42%79%
201239%19%45%37%76%
201336%14%46%39%75%
201430%16%44%39%73%
201522%19%43%33%70%
20169%13%41%30%68%
20177%17%37%30%68%
20185%14%36%27%67%
20192%5%29%23%65%
20202%2%24%19%64%
20212%2%28%22%63%
20222%3%32%19%62%
20231%1%25%16%61%
20241%1%22%15%58%
20250%0%21%16%55%

Carbon pricing: what the research says

B
Level of evidence B

Several quasi-experimental studies, on different countries and sectors, agree: putting a price on emissions makes them fall, without a collapse in the output of the firms concerned. These are not controlled experiments, and the effect depends on the level of the price and on the alternatives available.

  • B
    Andersson (2019), American Economic Journal: Economic PolicyMethod: Sweden’s 1991 carbon tax on motor fuels, compared with a “synthetic control” of OECD countries without a similar tax

    Transport emissions fell clearly against the control group, and the tax cut consumption more than an equivalent rise in the market price.

  • B
    Colmer, Martin, Muûls and Wagner (2025), Review of Economic StudiesMethod: French manufacturing firms covered by the EU emissions trading system compared with similar firms not covered, plant-level data

    Covered firms cut their emissions with no measurable fall in output or jobs, mostly by investing in less emitting processes.

  • B
    Leroutier (2022), Journal of Environmental Economics and ManagementMethod: the UK carbon price floor of 2013, British electricity compared with a synthetic control of European countries

    The price floor explains much of the rapid fall of coal in British electricity after 2013.

The scale
  • A: causal effect shown by several studies with a rigorous design (experiment, reform compared with a control group), in several countries.
  • B: causal effect shown by at least one rigorous study, or several quasi-experimental studies that agree.
  • C: strong correlations and a plausible mechanism, no causal proof.
  • D: descriptive observation or expert opinion only.

3. Wind and sun

Denmark began installing wind turbines in the 1980s and now gets 70% of its electricity from wind and solar. Germany (45%) and Spain (42%) followed from the 2000s, with guaranteed feed-in tariffs then auctions. China (22%) now installs on its own most of the world’s new panels and turbines. France is at 14%.

These early countries paid dearly for the first installations; their effort helped bring costs down for everyone. Today solar and onshore wind are among the cheapest ways to produce new electricity. The difficulty moves to the grid, storage and supply when there is neither wind nor sun.

Share of wind and solar in electricity generation

Sum of the shares of wind and solar in the country’s generation (Ember).

  • France
  • United States
  • China
  • United Kingdom
  • Germany
  • Spain
  • Denmark

Source:EmberType of source : Research

Show the chart data
PeriodDenmarkSpainGermanyUnited KingdomChinaUnited StatesFrance
200012%2%2%0%0%0%0%
200111%3%2%0%0%0%0%
200212%4%3%0%0%0%0%
200312%5%3%0%0%0%0%
200416%6%4%0%0%0%0%
200518%7%5%1%0%0%0%
200613%8%5%1%0%1%0%
200718%9%7%1%0%1%1%
200819%11%7%2%0%1%1%
200919%15%8%2%1%2%2%
201020%17%8%3%1%2%2%
201128%18%12%4%2%3%3%
201234%21%13%6%2%4%3%
201334%24%13%8%3%4%4%
201443%24%15%11%3%5%4%
201551%23%19%14%4%6%5%
201644%23%18%14%5%7%5%
201750%23%22%18%6%8%6%
201849%23%24%21%8%9%7%
201958%26%29%23%8%10%8%
202061%30%32%28%9%12%10%
202153%33%28%25%12%13%10%
202261%34%33%29%14%15%12%
202368%40%40%33%16%16%14%
202469%43%43%35%18%17%13%
202570%42%45%36%22%19%14%

Solar and wind: what the research says

C
Level of evidence C

The fall in the cost of solar, wind and batteries is a measured fact, and it goes faster as installations multiply. That a given country’s feed-in tariffs or auctions caused it has not been established by controlled studies: it is a long-run correlation, solid but not proof.

  • C
    Way, Ives, Mealy and Farmer (2022), JouleMethod: cost series of dozens of technologies over several decades, experience curves tested on their past forecasts

    The cost of solar, wind and batteries falls at a steady rate with each doubling of installed capacity; a fast transition would cost less than a status quo based on fossil fuels.

The scale
  • A: causal effect shown by several studies with a rigorous design (experiment, reform compared with a control group), in several countries.
  • B: causal effect shown by at least one rigorous study, or several quasi-experimental studies that agree.
  • C: strong correlations and a plausible mechanism, no causal proof.
  • D: descriptive observation or expert opinion only.

4. Heating homes

Sweden (68%), Finland (63%) and Denmark (56%) produce more than half of their heat from renewable energy, against 31% in France, 18% in Germany, 11% in the Netherlands and 27% in the European Union. These countries built district heating fed by wood and waste, and made heat pumps common, helped by high taxes on heating oil and gas.

Insulation is the other lever, but rigorous evaluations call for caution about the savings really obtained. The Netherlands shows the weight of history: a country heated with gas from its own field starts further back.

Share of renewable energy in heating and cooling

Buildings and industry, by the method of the European directive (Eurostat, SHARES). European Union countries only.

  • European Union
  • Netherlands
  • Germany
  • France
  • Denmark
  • Finland
  • Sweden

Source:Eurostat

Show the chart data
PeriodSwedenFinlandDenmarkFranceGermanyNetherlandsEuropean Union
200446%40%21%13%7%2%12%
200549%39%23%12%8%2%12%
200652%41%24%12%8%3%13%
200754%41%27%13%10%3%15%
200856%43%28%13%10%3%15%
200959%43%29%15%11%3%17%
201057%44%30%16%12%3%17%
201159%46%32%15%13%4%17%
201261%48%33%17%13%4%19%
201362%51%35%18%13%4%19%
201463%52%38%18%13%5%20%
201563%53%40%19%13%5%20%
201663%54%41%20%13%5%20%
201764%55%44%21%13%6%21%
201863%55%45%21%14%6%22%
201964%57%47%22%15%7%22%
202066%58%51%23%14%8%23%
202169%52%52%25%16%8%23%
202270%58%51%27%17%9%25%
202367%61%55%30%17%10%26%
202468%63%56%31%18%11%27%
2025––––––27%

Renovating and heating differently: what the research says

A
Level of evidence A

The few controlled experiments on housing teach caution: the real savings of renovation are often well below engineers’ estimates, while simple comparative information cuts consumption a little, at very low cost. Switching to heat pumps has not been evaluated that way; the studies available mostly describe the policies of the countries that made them common.

  • A
    Fowlie, Greenstone and Wolfram (2018), Quarterly Journal of EconomicsMethod: controlled experiment: thousands of Michigan households randomly encouraged to have their home insulated for free

    Measured energy savings reach only a fraction of those the engineering models predicted, and the cost of the works exceeds the gains.

  • A
    Allcott (2011), Journal of Public EconomicsMethod: controlled experiments on hundreds of thousands of US households receiving or not a report comparing their consumption with their neighbours’

    The comparative report cuts electricity use by a few percent, at a very low cost per tonne avoided.

  • C
    Rosenow, Gibb, Nowak and Lowes (2022), Nature EnergyMethod: review of the policies of the countries where heat pumps became common (Sweden, Norway, Finland and others)

    The leading countries combine a tax on heating oil or gas, purchase grants and standards for new buildings; no single measure is enough.

The scale
  • A: causal effect shown by several studies with a rigorous design (experiment, reform compared with a control group), in several countries.
  • B: causal effect shown by at least one rigorous study, or several quasi-experimental studies that agree.
  • C: strong correlations and a plausible mechanism, no causal proof.
  • D: descriptive observation or expert opinion only.

5. Cars

In 2025, 97% of new cars sold in Norway were electric, against 22% in 2015. The country exempted them from VAT and its heavy registration tax, gave them user advantages (tolls, parking) and multiplied charging points, financed in part by its oil revenue. Next come Sweden (61%) and China (53%), where domestic carmakers sell cheap models. France is at 26%, Germany at 30%, the United States at 10%, the world at 25%.

An electric car cuts emissions only as much as the electricity that charges it is clean, hence the order of the work. Reducing traffic itself is another lever: Stockholm’s congestion charge is one of the best evaluated.

Share of electric cars in new car sales

Battery-electric and plug-in hybrids (IEA, Global EV Outlook, via Our World in Data).

  • World
  • United States
  • Germany
  • France
  • China
  • Sweden
  • Norway

Source:IEA

Show the chart data
PeriodNorwaySwedenChinaFranceGermanyUnited StatesWorld
20123%0%0%0%0%0%0%
20136%1%0%1%0%1%0%
201415%1%0%1%0%1%0%
201522%2%1%1%1%1%1%
201629%3%2%1%1%1%1%
201739%5%2%2%2%1%1%
201849%8%5%2%2%2%2%
201956%11%5%3%3%2%3%
202075%32%6%11%14%2%4%
202186%43%16%17%26%5%9%
202289%54%29%20%31%8%15%
202390%60%38%25%24%10%18%
202492%58%48%24%20%10%21%
202597%61%53%26%30%10%25%

Cars and traffic: what the research says

B
Level of evidence B

The Norwegian case and Stockholm’s congestion charge are well studied, with quasi-experimental methods or before-and-after comparisons around a full-scale trial. Their results are solid for these two countries; their size elsewhere depends on the price of electricity, public transport and the cost of the measures.

  • B
    Springel (2021), American Economic Journal: Economic PolicyMethod: the Norwegian electric car market modelled from sales and the location of chargers, subsidies to cars and to chargers compared

    Purchase incentives and charging points reinforce each other; early in the take-up, a krone spent on chargers sold more electric cars than a krone of purchase subsidy.

  • B
    Börjesson, Eliasson, Hugosson and Brundell-Freij (2012), Transport PolicyMethod: Stockholm congestion charge, seven-month trial in 2006 then permanent introduction, traffic measured before, during and after

    Traffic across the cordon fell clearly and lastingly, so did emissions in the centre, and the charge, unpopular before the trial, was accepted by a majority afterwards.

The scale
  • A: causal effect shown by several studies with a rigorous design (experiment, reform compared with a control group), in several countries.
  • B: causal effect shown by at least one rigorous study, or several quasi-experimental studies that agree.
  • C: strong correlations and a plausible mechanism, no causal proof.
  • D: descriptive observation or expert opinion only.

6. Cutting emissions without ceasing to grow

The chart places 36 countries by the change in their output and emissions since 2005. In 29 of them, output rose and emissions fell. In the United Kingdom, GDP grew by 27% and emissions fell by 46%; in the United States, GDP grew by 38% and emissions fell by 15%.

The level matters too: an American emits 19.0 t per head on the territory, a German 7.8 t per head, a French person 5.4 t per head and a Swede 4.5 t per head, for similar living standards. These comparisons do not tell everything: they exclude the emissions of imported goods, larger for countries that moved their industry abroad.

GDP growth and change in emissions since 2005, OECD countries

Horizontally: change in real GDP (World Bank). Vertically: change in greenhouse-gas emissions on the territory, excluding forests and land (inventories compiled by the OECD). Latest year published for each country.

  • Countries discussed
  • Other countries
Tap or hover over a dot to see which country it is.
−50050050100150GDP growth since 2005 (%)Change in emissions since 2005 (%)NorwaySpainFranceUnited KingdomDenmarkSwedenGermanyJapanUnited States

Source:OECD·World Bank

Show the chart data
CountryGDP growth since 2005 (%)Change in emissions since 2005 (%)Period
Greece−7%−46%2005 – 2024
Italy5%−39%2005 – 2024
Japan10%−24%2005 – 2024
Finland14%−44%2005 – 2024
Portugal20%−40%2005 – 2024
France23%−34%2005 – 2024
Germany24%−34%2005 – 2024
Spain24%−39%2005 – 2024
Austria25%−28%2005 – 2024
United Kingdom27%−46%2005 – 2024
Mexico28%21%2005 – 2022
Denmark29%−45%2005 – 2024
Belgium32%−32%2005 – 2024
Netherlands33%−35%2005 – 2024
Latvia35%−12%2005 – 2024
Norway36%−18%2005 – 2024
Sweden38%−28%2005 – 2024
United States38%−15%2005 – 2022
Estonia38%−47%2005 – 2024
Hungary39%−31%2005 – 2024
Canada41%−10%2005 – 2024
Czechia44%−34%2005 – 2024
Switzerland45%−29%2005 – 2024
Slovenia45%−25%2005 – 2024
Luxembourg50%−42%2005 – 2024
New Zealand51%−11%2005 – 2024
Iceland52%17%2005 – 2024
Australia63%−2%2005 – 2024
Chile69%46%2005 – 2022
Lithuania72%−17%2005 – 2024
Slovakia75%−35%2005 – 2024
South Korea76%18%2005 – 2023
Poland101%−15%2005 – 2024
Israel104%9%2005 – 2024
Ireland142%−23%2005 – 2024
Türkiye149%69%2005 – 2024

Living standards and emissions per head, OECD countries

Horizontally: GDP per head in constant dollars at purchasing power parity (World Bank). Vertically: tonnes of CO2 equivalent emitted on the territory per head.

  • Countries discussed
  • Other countries
Tap or hover over a dot to see which country it is.
5101525,00050,00075,000100,000125,000GDP per head ($ PPP)Emissions per head (t)NorwaySpainFranceDenmarkSwedenGermanyJapanUnited StatesFinland

Source:OECD·World Bank

Show the chart data
CountryGDP per head ($ PPP)Emissions per head (t)Period
Mexico$21,3925.9 t per head2022
Chile$29,5605.7 t per head2022
Türkiye$36,1546.8 t per head2024
Greece$37,4747.0 t per head2024
Latvia$37,6155.2 t per head2024
Slovakia$40,3026.2 t per head2024
Hungary$40,7475.6 t per head2024
Estonia$41,1867.5 t per head2024
Portugal$42,2284.8 t per head2024
Poland$45,1539.3 t per head2024
Israel$47,3897.9 t per head2024
Lithuania$47,4626.3 t per head2024
Japan$47,4808.4 t per head2024
Czechia$47,9738.8 t per head2024
New Zealand$48,32514.3 t per head2024
Spain$48,4605.5 t per head2024
Slovenia$48,6587.3 t per head2024
Italy$53,2856.2 t per head2024
United Kingdom$53,4125.4 t per head2024
South Korea$54,02913.7 t per head2023
France$54,7995.4 t per head2024
Finland$55,9017.0 t per head2024
Canada$57,53416.6 t per head2024
Australia$60,31019.1 t per head2024
Sweden$62,5584.5 t per head2024
Germany$62,6557.8 t per head2024
Belgium$63,3118.3 t per head2024
Austria$63,7887.3 t per head2024
Iceland$68,23012.4 t per head2024
Netherlands$70,4947.8 t per head2024
Denmark$71,0356.4 t per head2024
United States$72,82919.0 t per head2022
Switzerland$85,4484.4 t per head2024
Norway$94,8048.0 t per head2024
Ireland$118,83310.0 t per head2024
Luxembourg$128,47511.1 t per head2024

What we know, what we don’t

What the figures establish

  • The most advanced countries first decarbonised their electricity, through nuclear, hydro, then wind and solar.
  • Putting a price on carbon brings emissions down without a collapse in output, according to several quasi-experimental studies.
  • In most rich countries, output has risen since 2005 while emissions on the territory have fallen.

What they don’t tell

  • How much of the falls comes from policies rather than deindustrialisation, geography or old choices such as nuclear power.
  • How much greenhouse gas rich countries emit through the goods they import: these figures do not count it.
  • Whether measures that worked in small rich countries such as Norway would give the same results in large countries, at a bearable cost.

Stay up to date

This deep dive is updated at least once a quarter with the new figures. Follow it to get a notification at each update.

Sources

Series downloaded from their producers on Nov 15, 2026, the snapshot date. Only published periods are used: no projection.

  • Eurostat SHARES, share of renewable energy in heating and cooling (nrg_ind_ren)
  • IEA Global EV Outlook, electric car sales share (via Our World in Data)
  • OECD Greenhouse gas emissions inventories, total excluding LULUCF (DSD_AIR_GHG@DF_AIR_GHG)
  • World Bank World Development Indicators: population, real GDP, GDP per capita at PPP
  • Ember Type of source : Research Yearly electricity data, global release (share of generation by source)