JusticeFrance
Justice orientation and programming act 2023-2027
The act of 20 November 2023 sets the payment appropriations of the « Justice » budget mission (excluding pensions) from €9.58bn in 2023 to €10.75bn in 2027, 10,000 net job creations including 1,500 magistrates and 1,800 court clerks, and authorises a rewrite of the Code of Criminal Procedure by ordinance. An organic act passed alongside reforms the status of magistrates. The 2025 and 2026 budgets fell short of the path; the 2027 finance bill exceeds it.
Updated: November 3, 2026Next milestone: 2027 — Last year of the programming: €10.75bn programmed, 1,500 magistrates and 1,800 clerks to be reached
At a glance
Reference text
Loi n° 2023-1059 du 20 novembre 2023 d’orientation et de programmation du ministère de la justice 2023-2027 (Justice Ministry Orientation and Programming Act 2023-2027)[1][4]
No. 2023-1059 · November 20, 2023
Read the text ↗Carried by
- Éric Dupond-Moretti[4][5]Keeper of the Seals, Minister of Justice (garde des sceaux, ministre de la justice) — tabled the bill and the organic bill · 2023 · Initiator
- Gérald Darmanin[14]Keeper of the Seals, Minister of Justice (garde des sceaux, ministre de la justice), Sébastien Lecornu government — bill ratifying the Code of Criminal Procedure ordinance · 2026 · Implementation
Implementation
- Ministry of Justice
- Parliament — yearly finance acts (credits voted each year)
Stated objective
Give the justice system the means it needs to function efficiently: a multi-year path of resources reaching close to €11bn in 2027, 10,000 additional jobs, 15,000 additional prison places over 2018-2027, the digitalisation of the ministry and shorter processing times — a target average civil processing time of 11.5 months at the end of 2027.[7][1]
according to the government (statement of reasons and report annexed to the act)
Payment appropriations of the « Justice » mission, excluding pensions
€10.75bn
2027 · according to article 1 of the act[1][10]
+21% compared with the 2022 initial finance act (€8.862bn).
Net job creations at the Ministry of Justice
10,000
by 2027 (FTE) · according to article 1 of the act[1]
Includes 605 FTE recruited in 2022 for local justice.
Additional magistrates
1,500
by 2027 · according to article 1 of the act[1]
Additional court clerks (greffiers)
1,800
by 2027 · according to article 1 of the act[1][7]
The bill as tabled planned 1,500 clerks.
Additional prison places (construction programme)
15,000
2018-2027 · according to the report annexed to the act[1]
Single-cell occupancy rate across the prison estate
80%
target · according to the report annexed to the act[1]
Against 40.4% when the act was passed.
Main measures
- Yearly path of payment appropriations for the « Justice » mission, excluding pensions: €9.579bn in 2023, €10.081bn in 2024, €10.681bn in 2025, €10.691bn in 2026 and €10.748bn in 2027; a report to Parliament before 30 April every year.[1]
- 10,000 net job creations by 2027, including 1,500 magistrates and 1,800 court clerks; new posts of « attachés de justice » and specialised assistants to support magistrates (attachés may attend deliberations but not take part).[1][2]
- Authorisation to rewrite the legislative part of the Code of Criminal Procedure by ordinance within two years, without changing the substance of the law; the ordinance may take effect no earlier than one year after publication (a safeguard added by the Senate).[1][8][2]
- Criminal procedure changes: night searches in the flagrante delicto inquiry into crimes against persons, on the authorisation of the liberty and custody judge; remote activation of devices for geolocation; video medical examination in extended police custody under conditions — most in force since 30 September 2024.[2][1]
- Four-year experiment of « tribunaux des activités économiques » (economic activity courts) with a contribution for economic justice, evaluated in a report to Parliament at least six months before it ends.[1][2]
- Wage garnishment entrusted to a commissaire de justice instead of the enforcement judge (debtor’s suspensive appeal within one month), in force by 1 July 2025 at the latest.[2][1]
- Organic act no. 2023-1058: a professional competition replaces direct entry routes into the magistracy, a real third grade in the judicial hierarchy, honorary magistrates serving until 75, a reformed disciplinary procedure and better handling of litigants’ complaints.[9][3]
In data
2023-2027, billions of current euros, excluding pensions
| Year | 2023 act | Initial finance act | Finance bill | Executed |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | €9.58bn | €9.58bn | — | — |
| 2024 | €10.08bn | €10.08bn | — | €9.8bn |
| 2025 | €10.68bn | €10.47bn | — | — |
| 2026 | €10.69bn | — | €10.63bn | — |
| 2027 | €10.75bn | — | €10.96bn | — |
Scale starts at €0bn · Programmed amounts are not spending: each year’s credits are voted in the finance act. Only the figures read in official documents are shown: 2026 and 2027 = the bills as tabled (2027 still before Parliament); 2025 also lost €139m to a cancellation decree; executed spending is shown for 2024 only. On top of these credits, the 2027 bill counts earmarked revenues (legal aid contribution, appeal stamp duty).
Professional judges
7.9K
2023
Prisoners (total count)
75.9K
2023
Official prison capacity
61.8K
2023
Key figures
Judges per 100k
11.52per 100k
2023
Additional magistrates recruited
590
2023-2024 · Observed
according to the government’s 2024 report on the act[10]
Against 498 programmed; for court clerks, 370 against 438 programmed.
Payment appropriations executed, excluding pensions
€9.80bn
2024 · Observed
according to the government’s 2024 report on the act[10][1]
Against €10.084bn voted in the 2024 finance act and €10.081bn programmed.
Gross prison places delivered by the construction programme
7,684
autumn 2026 · Observed
according to the Ministry of Justice (2027 budget annex)[17]
26 facilities delivered, out of 15,000 additional places planned for 2027.
Prison density
143.7%
10 September 2026 · Observed
according to the Ministry of Justice (2027 budget annex)[17]
90,173 prisoners for 63,303 operational places, 8,538 of them sleeping on mattresses on the floor.
Timeline
- Under debate
Debate in the Senate, first chamber seized[4]
Bill adopted with amendments at first reading by the Assemblée nationale[4]
Joint committee (commission mixte paritaire) reaches an agreement[4]
Assemblée nationale adopts the joint committee text[4]
- Adopted
Final adoption by Parliament (Senate vote on the joint committee text)[4]
Constitutional Council decisions no. 2023-855 DC and no. 2023-856 DC[2][3]
Referred by more than sixty deputies on 16 October 2023, the Council strikes down the remote activation of electronic devices to capture sound and images (an excessive infringement of privacy, as it covered all organised-crime offences) and, as unrelated to the bill as tabled, articles 4, 5, 8, 10 and 20 and paragraph IV of article 49; remote geolocation and night searches are upheld, the latter with a reservation. On the organic act, referred by the Prime Minister, it strikes down the possibility for delegated or replacement magistrates to sit by audiovisual means.
Most criminal procedure provisions take effect[1]
- Upcoming — the outcome is not known
Deadline for the government’s yearly report to Parliament on the act’s execution[1]
Article 1 requires a report each year before 30 April, in particular on net job creations and their distribution among courts.
- Upcoming — the outcome is not known
New Code of Criminal Procedure due to take effect[14]
Date set by the ordinance; the pending ratification bill would allow a postponement by decree to 1 September 2030 at the latest.
The debate
Citoyen takes no position: arguments are reported as their authors put them.
According to its supporters
- The government presents the act as giving justice the means it needs to function efficiently: a budget close to €11bn in 2027, nearly 60% more over two presidential terms, funding pay rises, 15,000 prison places, larger courthouses and digitalisation.[7]
- For the Minister of Justice, the organic act implements the recommendations of the États généraux de la justice for magistrates and is one of the most important statutory reforms of the judiciary since 1958, opening the corps to diverse careers and making magistrates more accountable.[9]
- The Assemblée nationale’s rapporteur for the justice budget considers the increases necessary: France remains, according to the Council of Europe’s CEPEJ, among the countries investing the least in justice (€77.2 per inhabitant against an average of €85.40), and credits must keep rising beyond 2026.[11]
According to its opponents
- The Senate law committee, while adopting both texts, judged them only an « approximate translation » of the États généraux de la justice, regretted that essential parameters of the magistrates’ status were left to decrees, and stressed that the annexed report has no binding force and commits only the government.[8]
- The more than sixty deputies who referred the act to the Constitutional Council (among them Mathilde Panot and André Chassaigne) argued that the remote activation of phones and other devices was a disproportionate invasion of privacy and that the budget path lacked a breakdown by programme and any update clause; the Council struck down remote sound and image capture but upheld geolocation and article 1.[2]
- The same Assemblée nationale rapporteur notes that the path was not met two years running: the 2025 finance act fell €221m short, before €139m was cancelled by decree, and the 2026 bill was about €60m below the annuity.[11]
Indicators to watch
- Professional judges per 100,000 inhabitants · EurostatSee the card →
- Prison population · EurostatSee the card →
- Official prison capacity · EurostatSee the card →
- Average processing time of civil cases (target 11.5 months at end-2027) · Ministère de la Justiceno Citoyen card yet
- Prison occupancy rate · Ministère de la Justice (DAP)no Citoyen card yet
- Justice budget per inhabitant · CEPEJ (Conseil de l’Europe)no Citoyen card yet
Sources
- [1]Loi n° 2023-1059 du 20 novembre 2023 d’orientation et de programmation du ministère de la justice 2023-2027 (JORF n° 269 du 21 novembre 2023), avec rapport annexé — Légifrance, November 21, 2023
- [2]Décision n° 2023-855 DC du 16 novembre 2023 — Loi d’orientation et de programmation du ministère de la justice 2023-2027 — Conseil constitutionnel, November 16, 2023
- [3]Décision n° 2023-856 DC du 16 novembre 2023 — Loi organique relative à l’ouverture, à la modernisation et à la responsabilité du corps judiciaire — Conseil constitutionnel, November 16, 2023
- [4]Dossier législatif — Orientation et programmation du ministère de la justice 2023-2027 (projet de loi n° 569, 2022-2023) — Sénat
- [5]Dossier législatif — Loi organique relative à l’ouverture, à la modernisation et à la responsabilité du corps judiciaire (projet de loi organique n° 570, 2022-2023) — Sénat
- [6]Scrutin n° 300 du 13 juin 2023 sur l’ensemble du projet de loi d’orientation et de programmation du ministère de la justice 2023-2027 — Sénat, June 13, 2023
- [7]Projet de loi d’orientation et de programmation du ministère de la justice 2023-2027 — exposé des motifs — Sénat, May 3, 2023
- [8]L’essentiel sur le projet de loi d’orientation et de programmation du ministère de la justice 2023-2027 et le projet de loi organique relatif au corps judiciaire — commission des lois — Sénat, May 31, 2023
- [9]Circulaire du 5 décembre 2023 de présentation de la loi organique relative à l’ouverture, à la modernisation et à la responsabilité du corps judiciaire (JUSB2332600C) — Ministère de la Justice, December 5, 2023
- [10]Rapport annuel 2024 — Loi n° 2023-1059 du 20 novembre 2023 d’orientation et de programmation du ministère de la justice 2023-2027 — Ministère de la Justice, September 2025
- [11]Rapport n° 1996 sur le projet de loi de finances pour 2026, annexe n° 29 « Justice » (rapporteur spécial M. Jean-Didier Berger) — Assemblée nationale, October 23, 2025
- [12]Avis n° 2006 sur le projet de loi de finances pour 2026, tome V « Justice : justice et accès au droit » (Mme Gabrielle Cathala) — Assemblée nationale, October 27, 2025
- [13]Compte rendu du Conseil des ministres du 19 novembre 2025 — ordonnance portant réécriture du code de procédure pénale — Élysée, November 19, 2025
- [14]Projet de loi n° 604 (2025-2026) ratifiant l’ordonnance n° 2025-1091 du 19 novembre 2025 portant réécriture du code de procédure pénale (partie législative) — Sénat, May 6, 2026
- [15]Dossier législatif — Projet de loi ratifiant l’ordonnance n° 2025-1091 du 19 novembre 2025 portant réécriture du code de procédure pénale — Sénat
- [16]Projet de loi de finances pour 2027, n° 3210, enregistré le 1er octobre 2026 — Assemblée nationale, October 1, 2026
- [17]Projet annuel de performances — Annexe au projet de loi de finances pour 2027, mission « Justice » — Gouvernement — annexe au projet de loi de finances (publiée par l’Assemblée nationale), October 2026